Hybrid Scorecard

See  which vehicles make the most of hybrid technology for the environment, and your pocketbook.

Toyota Prius

(compared with the Toyota Matrix)

Enviro. Score
(0 to 10, 10 being best)

Hybrid Value
(Very Low to Very High)

Forced Features
(None to $$$$$)

 9.8

 Very High

 $$

 
2010 Toyota Matrix MSRP
$17,360
 
 
Cost of Hybridization
$3,040
 
 
Forced Features
$1,600
 
 
2010 Toyota Prius MSRP
$22,000
 


NOTE: Pricing based on data collected October 2009. Costs of hybridization and forced features are UCS estimates based on information available on manufacturer websites.
See full Hybrid Scorecard methodology

Vehicle Summary
Toyota first introduced the Prius in model year 2001 and the 2010 model represents the third generation of the vehicle. It is a midsize car that seats five people and gets a combined EPA estimated fuel economy of 50 mpg. Since the Prius is a dedicated hybrid (i.e., there is no conventional counterpart), it was compared with the Toyota Matrix with a 1.8L engine. The Matrix was chosen for its comparable size and performance to the Prius. The Prius is a full hybrid, offering electric-only operation under certain conditions, idle stop/start, power assist, and regenerative braking.

Environmental Score
With a 44 percent reduction in global warming emissions compared with the Matrix, the Prius gets the largest percent reduction of global warming emissions of any other hybrid on the market. The smog-forming emissions performance of the Prius is very good, earning it an EPA air pollution score of 9.5. These two factors give the Prius an Environmental Score of 9.8, the strongest Environmental Score of all the hybrids currently on the market.
Scorecard Environmental Score methodology

Hybrid Value
Comparing costs with a similarly featured 2010 Matrix, we calculate that Toyota is charging $3,040 for the hybrid system in the Prius. With an outstanding 44 percent reduction in global warming emissions, this gives the Prius a Hybrid Value rating of “Very High”—the best rating possible. Interestingly enough, only the Prius and another dedicated hybrid model—the Lexus HS 250h, merit a “Very High” in this category. The other dedicated hybrid model on the market, the Honda Insight, gets only a “Medium” for Hybrid Value due to a 24 percent global warming emissions reduction over the conventional Honda Fit.
Scorecard Hybrid Value methodology

Forced Features
Toyota offers four different option packages, called “trim levels,” for the Prius (Prius II–Prius V). The Prius II is the least expensive trim level, but still comes with $1,600 worth of extra features compared with the base model Matrix. This gives the Prius a Forced Features rating of “$$”. Toyota announced it is going to offer a Prius I trim level that will have fewer features for $1,000 less. Reports, however, indicate the Prius I will be made available primarily for filling fleet orders. The individual consumer would have to place a special order for one. Sample forced features on the Prius with trim level II include heated outside mirrors; smart key system on driver's door with push button start and remote illuminated entry; remote keyless entry system with 2-stage unlocking and panic function; and enhanced vehicle stability control with traction control. Click to see the full list of forced features for this trim level.
Scorecard Forced Features methodology

Hybrid Scorecard Home


Additional Info
Visit the Who’s Got Hybrids section to read comments and stories from actual hybrid owners.

Visit the Reviews page to see what popular automotive websites think of this hybrid.

 

  SIGN UP FOR THE HYBRIDCENTER  DRIVING CHANGE NETWORK
to get updates to our Hybrid Scorecard and the latest on the hybrid vehicle market delivered right to your email box.
 
  Contact information:

*

Name:

 

 

   

*

 

City/State/ZIP:

 

    

 

Are you new to the Union of Concerned Scientists online community? By filling out this form you will receive periodic updates and communications from UCS.


 


   Please leave this field empty

 

webby logoapex logo ucs logo
kraemer logo